The Hidden Truth: 8 Things You Can't Discover Just by Reading Skincare Ingredient Lists

As skincare enthusiasts, we've all been there—standing in the beauty aisle, carefully scrutinizing ingredient lists as if they hold the secrets to perfect skin. But what if we told you that even the most detailed ingredient analysis might be missing crucial information? In a recent episode of the Facially Conscious Podcast, "7 Things You Can't Determine from the Ingredient List," cosmetic chemist Rebecca Gadberry and esthetician Trina Renea revealed some eye-opening truths that challenge everything we think we know about reading product labels.

The Ingredient List Isn't the Full Story

"A lot of people think of the ingredient list as God, as the Bible, as the Word," explains Rebecca Gadberry during the podcast. "They think that you can tell anything by reading the ingredient list." However, the reality is much more complicated than what you see in tiny print on your product packaging.

The Fair Packaging and Labeling Act (FPLA), which took effect in the 1970s, requires ingredients to be listed on outer packaging to help consumers identify potential allergens. While this was a major step forward for consumer safety, it also had an unintended downside: we often throw away the packaging and lose access to ingredient information when we actually need it—after using the product and possibly having a reaction.

1. Ingredient Quality and Purity Standards

The most shocking revelation from the podcast is that ingredient names don't indicate quality or purity. Take cocamidopropyl betaine, a common gentle cleansing ingredient. "There are various purity standards applied to this ingredient," Gadberry explains. "So you can have a purity standard that has a lot of impurities in it that it's made to be used in mechanics... not made to be used on the skin."

The cosmetic industry uses several grades:

• Technical/Mechanical grade: Used for engines and machinery
• Cosmetic grade: High purity standard for skincare
• Drug grade (USP): The purest standard available

The problem? All grades appear the same on ingredient lists. A typical example is mineral oil, which has been criticized because studies on technical-grade mineral oil showed it contained carcinogens and irritants. However, USP-grade mineral oil is completely pure and non-comedogenic.

2. Ingredient Source and Origin

You can't tell whether glycerin comes from plants, animals, or petroleum just by reading the label. "Most ingredients these days that are like glycerin or your stearates... are plant-derived, if they have a choice between plant, animal, or petroleum," notes Gadberry. "But check. To do that, you need to contact the company."

3. Consistency and Standardization of Plant Extracts

This is where things become especially complicated. Plants are "chemical factories" with diverse chemistry influenced by many factors: where they're grown, how they're cultivated, harvest timing, fertilizer use, and water availability. Without proper chemical standardization through fingerprint analysis, you can't be sure if that green tea extract in your serum contains the same beneficial compounds from one batch to another.

In the past, when a product labeled as 'natural' changed color, companies would say, 'That's because it's a plant and it's natural and it changes,' Gadberry explains. "But we now know that when something changes in color, its chemistry is also changing."

4. Impurities and Contaminants

Some emulsifiers and surfactants may contain 1,4-dioxane impurities, but these don't show up on ingredient labels. Ingredients with PEGs or PPGs might have these impurities, but they can also be removed during manufacturing. The only way to be sure is to ask the manufacturer directly.

5. Sustainable and Ethical Sourcing

That palm oil in your moisturizer could be sustainably sourced or it might contribute to deforestation. The ingredient list won't reveal which. While organizations like the Responsible Palm Oil Initiative exist, not all companies participate, and sustainable sourcing isn't always certified.

6. Ingredient Percentages

Even the order of ingredients can be misleading. While ingredients must be listed in descending order of predominance, after 1%, companies can list ingredients in any order they choose. "If an ingredient is at the very beginning of the ingredient list, that doesn't mean that it's in there at very great amounts," Gadberry clarifies. This is crucial for ingredients like hyaluronic acid, which should only be used at 1% or less—higher concentrations can actually dehydrate the skin.

7. Fragrance Composition

When you see "fragrance" on a label, you don't really know what's inside. It might be synthetic chemicals or natural ingredients mixed in a lab, but regulations don't require companies to specify "natural fragrance." You also can't tell what diluants or other substances are part of that fragrance blend.

8. Green Chemistry Compliance

You can't tell if ingredients are produced according to green chemistry principles—the cradle-to-cradle approach that ensures sustainable manufacturing, avoids petroleum-based ingredients, and promotes environmentally responsible disposal methods. This differs from green marketing and represents the future of responsible cosmetic production.

What Can You Do?

The solution isn't to completely abandon ingredient lists, but to dig deeper. "Ask the brand how they prove the product is safe," recommends Gadberry. "That's going to tell you. Not just reading the ingredient list, not going to a doctor and having them tell you what they think, because doctors are not chemists."

Here are practical steps you can take:

1. Contact manufacturers directly with specific questions about ingredient grades, sources, and purity
2. Ask open-ended questions rather than yes/no questions to get more honest answers
3. Look for companies that are transparent about their sourcing and manufacturing processes
4. Focus on how companies prove safety rather than trying to decode ingredient lists alone

The Bottom Line

While ingredient lists offer helpful details, they are just the first step in truly understanding what you're applying to your skin. As Gadberry explains, "Even I can't tell a lot of times from reading an ingredient list. I have to dig deeper."

The next time you're evaluating a skincare product, remember that the most expensive serum at a high-end retailer might contain the same basic ingredients as a drugstore option—often, the difference is in the details you can't see on the label.

For more insights like these, listen to the full episode of "7 Things You Can't Determine from the Ingredient List" and find out why sometimes the best skincare approach is asking the right questions instead of trying to decode every ingredient name.

Join our Substack

To read more from Trina Reneá, join her on Substack